Player

Monday, May 17, 2010

Invasion of the "Diga Duns"

If you have gotten this far on this blog you most likely are wondering what in the fucking world I am talking about? What the fuck is a "Diga Dun" A little bit of back story should clear up this seemingly moronic made up word. Actually its not really a word at all but really a phonetic representation or onomatopoeia of an overused musical tool which is ubiquitous in the local music scene; the dreaded "breakdown". If you are reading this and don't know what a "breakdown" is in the context of metalcore music then I shall explain. Breakdowns usually involve repeated, heavily palm muted open notes on a drop tuned guitar in which the bass drum in synchronized with the open notes. Often there is a complete tempo change to accommodate the breakdown riff as well as a jarring, abrupt transitions from a verse or bridge riff with cymbal count offs and barky metalcore vocal introduction. The repetitions of open notes can be be triplets or quads or even single open notes depending upon the tempo or what have you. Breakdowns are placed anywhere in a song, but often times at the end of the song after some long, rung out open chord.

See this YouTube video for generic, boring metalcore breakdowns.

But moving on, I can't say I coined the term "Diga Dun" or anything but I do remember when I first conceptualized the term. I believe it was junior year of high school and I had a study hall in the cafeteria with a bunch of friends/acquaintances. One particular individual (I will keep all involved nameless) would often mimic the sound of the guitars in a breakdown. "Diga Dun Diga Dun Diga Dun Diga Dun Diga....". I will pause now so that you the reader can now out loud repeat the previous sentence and that will shed some enlightenment on what I am talking about..................
Finished? You probably did not do it anyways. After hearing said person often mimic the sound I simply spelled out the phonetic representation of the sound, "Diga Dun".

I don't remember when I first started referring to any breakdown in a song as "The Diga Duns" but that terminology stuck in my brain and several other people. Junior year of high school was the time when metalcore, hardcore or whatevercore was riding its peak of popularity in the metal scene. It definitely seized a perfect moment to capture the metal scene after a decade of near stagnant creation of a popular metal genre. The process was similar to the way thrash took over everything in the 80s and eventually became a identifier of the metal scene in America and Europe.

Like any surging trend in music, the archetypal tools and schema found in the bands of the time, (Killswitch, Unearth, Bury Your Dead, blah blah insert whatever core band here) filtered down into the local bands. Breakdowns became a staple of the music like cheesy tapping solos in 80's hair metal bands used for the quick, cheap mosh effect. As time wore on, more and more bands coming up in the local metal scene had more and more breakdowns and less and less songwriting. I don't know where people came up with the idea that slapping a bunch of incoherent riffs in some random order with a couple of already used breakdowns counts as some mighty progressive songwriting because that is just a load of bullshit. Combine this with bad vocalists, and half rate music gear (5150s, Sorry if that is what you roll with) and that is how shitty the metal scene is around here nowadays. Don't get me wrong, there is/was a few local bands who avoided this type of crap but by far and large this is and has been the plague of the local metal scene. I recently went to a show at the Webster in Hartford, and this is a problem with a lot of the bands who played that night. It is entirely possible that my friends who played in metalcore bands back in that day or play in one right now are reading this (and yes I also briefly had a metalcore band back then too). No need to be personally offended by my particular opinion on this matter just that in retrospec this is the opinion I have garnered.

If you have gotten this far without getting into some kind of tizzy then either you are an extremely patient person, haven't the faintest clue what I am talking about, or you share similar musical taste as I do. I don't mean to say that any breakdown is a shitty piece of shit that should not be used at all in a song but that breakdowns have come to be the failure of metal. It is time to move beyond having a breakdown in every song, comprising of the same open notes or dissonant chords with slightly modified tempos and beats with barky, psuedo-threatning vocals. Breakdowns get old and have little staying value in the long run. Yea you can get those shitty fanboys to dance or whatever every time you play at some half rate fuckin' club but as times goes on we all get bored. There is nothing special or memorable about a breakdown because they are all primarily rooted in the same sound, and same beat.

Breakdowns do not need to be abandoned or rejected by definition but need to be reworked, rethought and less used. For example, check this YouTube video of a Superjoint Ritual song, "Personal Insult". (Warning, quite a coarse video, coarse topic which I do not personally endorse. It is just a brutal, heavy song.) Around the 2:30 mark, they transition into a breakdown. If you take the time to listen to the entire record, or catalog from the band you will notice sparing use of breakdowns, maybe a handful across 2 great albums. A good combination of punk, Sabbath, sludge, metal, and of course Phil Anselmo.

There are definitely other types of problems in the local scene besides the abuse of breakdowns and I am not attempting to forget those issues and distract from them by only mentioning one issue in this blog post. As a last note, just remember this is my opinion on the matter which I have attempted to elucidate. You are entitled to simply say, fuck off you dick to what I just wrote but I believe it would be nonconstructive to do so.

3 comments:

  1. Very good haha, I must be honest and say I like some breakdowns, I think they can be tastefully applied and fun. For a really good early example check out the breakdown in "Mass Hypnosis" by Sepultura (1989). I like some metalcore still, the bands that originally were out that popularized it I still enjoy. (and yes...1 or 2 deathcore bands are good too) I do agree though that they've become a ridiculous excuse for every jerk in the audience with too much testosterone to suddenly think its ok to be a huge asshole

    Be careful using superjoint as your juxtaposition though, a lot of Phils lyrics can be immature and overly "I'm so fucking aggressive, fuck fuck fuck!!!", you know? I love Down though, and Pantera of course.

    For the bands you referenced specifically, I actually think Killswitch Engage is a legitimately respectable band, as for Bury Your Dead, their first 2 albums are straight-ahead good hardcore, but they've morphed into NU-metal garbage now. If their influence has frustrated you too much to appreciate them I can understand, but don't let that principle cancel out whatever admirable features they have.

    Breakdowns in general emerge from the hardcore punk scene in the 1980's, and as metal and punk overlap from time to time, they borrow from eachother.

    I only offer this up for the sake of argument. Believe me, I can't stand when bands just slap some generic riffing in drop-B in as a verse then suddenly do a breakdown followed by some weird emo-ish signing. So much of this crap has come out from sooo many bands that its killing the attributes it overdoses on. Breakdowns are great until they get overused and purged of their speciality....their supposed to be a surprise! thats what was so awesome about them in the first place. Anyway, sorry for the long response.

    Best,

    Drew

    ReplyDelete
  2. Drew

    Thanks for the detailed comment.

    "Be careful using superjoint as your juxtaposition though, a lot of Phils lyrics can be immature and overly "I'm so fucking aggressive, fuck fuck fuck!!!", you know? I love Down though, and Pantera of course."

    True, sometimes Phil's lyrics can verge into banal repetitions but I guess I have more respect for his lyrics and singing than any upstart metalcore band. I referenced SJR just to clarify that I do not believe breakdowns are categorically bad and useless just in need of overhaul.

    "For the bands you referenced specifically, I actually think Killswitch Engage is a legitimately respectable band, as for Bury Your Dead, their first 2 albums are straight-ahead good hardcore, but they've morphed into NU-metal garbage now. If their influence has frustrated you too much to appreciate them I can understand, but don't let that principle cancel out whatever admirable features they have."

    I liked KSE when they had Jesse singing rather than Howard. Right after Jesse left and they cut End of Heartache I totally lost much interest in the band. Nowadays they come off as totally pretentious and sold out. I don't think this is Howard's fault just that becoming so mainstream has radically changed their sound.

    As far as Bury Your Dead, Cover Your Tracks was a great album I wore out senior year of high school. As long as you recognize its shortcoming its an enjoyable album.

    "I only offer this up for the sake of argument. Believe me, I can't stand when bands just slap some generic riffing in drop-B in as a verse then suddenly do a breakdown followed by some weird emo-ish signing. So much of this crap has come out from sooo many bands that its killing the attributes it overdoses on. Breakdowns are great until they get overused and purged of their speciality....their supposed to be a surprise! thats what was so awesome about them in the first place. Anyway, sorry for the long response."

    I think my real criticism of breakdowns is not the bands who brought them to the forefront of the metal scene circa early 2000s but they way in which the local scenes quickly adopted it as a generic archetype for metal music and the subsequent reliance on breakdowns for musical cred. The fact that 10 years later, new metal bands are still trying that same formula it extremely boring.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In a way, its a by-product of the structure of pop-culture, siphoning out one aspect of a style that people listen to and deciding to explode it into its own obsessive fixation. Simplified from a capitalistic sense:

    "Milking it for all its worth"

    ReplyDelete